The protection perception gap: why confidence doesn't always mean resilience

Daren Boys, Protection Portfolio Distribution Director at Aviva, explores what new research tells us about the gap between feeling financially protected and having the right protection in place, and how advisers can help clients build genuine financial resilience.

Most people like to believe they're prepared for the unexpected. 

Whether it's protecting their income, supporting their family or safeguarding the life they've worked hard to build, confidence that things would be taken care of if circumstances suddenly changed can be reassuring. 

But confidence and preparedness aren't always the same thing. 

New research from Aviva reveals a significant disconnect between how protected people feel and the practical measures they've put in place to protect themselves and their loved ones. 

For advisers, understanding this gap presents an important opportunity to help clients move from confidence to genuine financial resilience. 

Confidence is high, but is it justified?

Our research found that 58% of UK adults are confident their loved ones would be financially and practically protected if they could no longer contribute towards the family income. On the surface, that's encouraging. It suggests many people feel positive about their financial situation and their ability to support those around them. 

However, when we looked more closely at protection ownership, a different picture emerged. 

Just 48% of respondents said they currently have financial protection in place, such as life insurance or income protection. More strikingly, only 30% said they have protection they believe is sufficient, while a further 13% admitted they aren't sure whether the cover they have would actually meet their needs. 

In other words, many people are confident about their financial resilience despite either having no protection at all or being uncertain whether their arrangements are adequate. 

That suggests confidence may be built on assumptions rather than regular reviews and informed planning. 

The danger of the "I'll sort it later" mindset

The research also sheds light on why this gap may persist. 

Among those without protection, 10% said they had been meaning to look into it, while 7% admitted they simply hadn't thought about it. A further 5% said they didn't know where to begin or didn't understand protection products well enough to take action. 

Perhaps most revealing of all, 13% of respondents said they hadn't even thought about whether their loved ones would be financially and practically protected if they were no longer able to contribute to the household. 

This highlights a challenge advisers will recognise. 

Protection is rarely urgent until life makes it urgent. 

Unlike a mortgage application, a house purchase or a pension contribution deadline, protection can often remain at the bottom of a client's priority list. As a result, plans are delayed, assumptions go unchallenged and important conversations never happen. 

What prompts people to take action?

Understanding what drives people to review their protection can help advisers identify opportunities for more meaningful conversations. 

When asked what would prompt them to take out or review financial protection, 23% cited a health scare affecting themselves or somebody close to them, while 20% pointed to a change in income or employment. 

Yet the most common response was perhaps the most concerning. 

More than a quarter of respondents (28%) said there was nothing in particular that would prompt them to review their protection arrangements. 

For advisers, this presents both a challenge and an opportunity. 

If clients are unlikely to initiate reviews themselves, the adviser relationship becomes even more valuable in helping them reassess needs as circumstances evolve. 

Changes in income, family dynamics, debts, savings and responsibilities can all affect protection requirements. Regular conversations help ensure protection remains appropriate as life changes. 

Learning from previous generations

Financial attitudes don’t develop in isolation. Our research explored the role that conversations with parents or guardians can play in shaping people’s awareness of financial protection. 

Changes in income, family circumstances, debts, savings and responsibilities can all affect protection needs over time. Understanding the conversations and experiences that have influenced a client’s approach to financial resilience can therefore provide a useful starting point for advisers. 

Advisers are well placed to encourage clients to look beyond their immediate financial priorities and consider how their needs may change over time. Opening up conversations about family, future responsibilities and financial resilience can help clients think more broadly about the safeguards they have in place and whether these continue to reflect their circumstances.

Turning confidence into resilience

Confidence matters. It helps people feel secure about the future. 

But genuine resilience requires more than optimism. 

The findings from the research suggest many consumers feel positive about their ability to withstand financial shocks, yet fewer have reviewed whether their protection arrangements truly support the life they've built. 

For advisers, that creates an opportunity to challenge assumptions and add real value. 

By helping clients regularly assess their protection needs, understand potential gaps and review existing arrangements, advisers can help transform confidence into something more meaningful: financial resilience that's built on planning rather than perception. 

Because when life changes unexpectedly, what matters isn't how protected people think they are. 

It's how protected they actually are.

 

 

Source

1]  Research conducted by Censuswide on behalf of Aviva among a sample of 2,000 UK consumers. Fieldwork was carried out between 24 June 2026 and 26 June 2026. Censuswide is a member of the Market Research Society (MRS) and the British Polling Council (BPC) and abides by the MRS Code of Conduct and ESOMAR principles.

AUTHOR

Daren Boys

Protection Portfolio Distribution Director,

Aviva